Case file · Sighting

William Rhodes's Phoenix photographs

On the evening of 7 July 1947 William A. Rhodes photographed a heel-shaped object over his home in Phoenix, Arizona; the Arizona Republic printed the pictures two days later.

1947 CE · 33.49, -112.07 · status: disputed

The account

Army intelligence and the FBI interviewed Rhodes and borrowed the negatives, and the case went into the Air Force's early files. It came in the same week as the Roswell announcement and the Twin Falls hoax, at the height of the 1947 flying-disc wave.

The sceptical view

Only two frames exist and there is no independent witness. Some researchers consider them a model; Project Blue Book's files list the case without a firm solution.

The researched reading

Two photographs of a heel-shaped object, taken during the 1947 craze. A model or hoax is the most likely explanation.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Undetermined40%The share the reading had given to fabrication on doubt rather than evidence: the record does not settle it either way.
Genuinely anomalous20%The Army and FBI took the photos seriously and Blue Book listed them without solution; but nothing in them requires a real craft.
A hoax or fabrication15%Only two frames exist, there is no independent witness, and the shape is consistent with a small model thrown or hung; Rhodes was an amateur with a flair for publicity in the 1947 craze.
Something known, misidentified12%A bird or distant aircraft could appear as a heel-shaped object in a photograph.
Secret human technology5%Secret aircraft were tested in 1947, but none matches the shape.
A known natural phenomenon3%No natural phenomenon fits a solid heel shape.
Perception, memory or mind3%The photographs, not memory, carry the case.
A poorly understood natural phenomenon2%Not applicable.

Official position: Army intelligence and the FBI interviewed Rhodes; Project Blue Book lists the case without a firm solution.

Connections in the atlas

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: 1947 flying disc craze
Open it in the living atlas