Case file · Anomaly hotspot

SS City of Glasgow vanishes

The Inman Line steamer City of Glasgow left Liverpool for Philadelphia on 1 March 1854 with about 480 people aboard, most of them emigrants, and was never heard from again.

1854 CE · 47.00, -35.00 · status: unexplained

The account

Six weeks later a ship reported passing a large steamer half sunk among ice floes, but it could not be identified. Position approximate.

The sceptical view

Ice in the North Atlantic, or fire, are the usual explanations.

The researched reading

An emigrant steamer lost on the North Atlantic. Ice or fire explain it.

ExplanationWeightWhy
A known natural phenomenon40%Ice was extensive in the North Atlantic in spring 1854; an iron screw steamer striking ice or foundering in a storm would sink with all aboard.
Undetermined20%The share a generic explanation had beyond what has been shown for this case: it fits many cases like this one, but has not been demonstrated for this one.
Something known, misidentified16%Fire, a frequent cause of steamship loss in the period, is an ordinary alternative.
Perception, memory or mind8%A loss of 480 people with no word invited rumours.
A hoax or fabrication6%Reports of a sighted wreck were unverified.
A poorly understood natural phenomenon4%Rogue waves are a known natural risk.
Genuinely anomalous4%Ice or fire explain it.
Secret human technology2%No hostile action in 1854.

Official position: No formal finding; the ship was presumed lost to ice or fire.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: SS City of Glasgow
  2. Iceberg (Wikipedia)
Open it in the living atlas