Case file · Sighting

Josephus' portents before the fall of Jerusalem

Josephus lists signs before the war with Rome: a sword-shaped star, a light round the altar at night, a temple gate that opened by itself, and chariots and armed troops seen running among the clouds.

66 CE · 31.78, 35.23 · status: account

The account

In The Jewish War (6.5.3) he says the sky armies were seen across the country before sunset, and that he would think it a fable had not eyewitnesses reported it. Tacitus (Histories 5.13) independently mentions armies clashing in the sky and a voice saying the gods were departing.

The sceptical view

Both writers composed their histories after 70 AD, when the disaster was known; the portents follow a classical genre.

Sources

  1. Josephus, The Jewish War 6.5.3 (Perseus)
  2. Wikipedia: Siege of Jerusalem (70 CE)
Open it in the living atlas