Case file · Fairy lore

The 'ladies from outside' of Sicily

Between 1579 and 1651 the Sicilian Inquisition in Palermo tried dozens of people, mostly women, who said they went out at night with the 'donne di fuori', fairy companies who blessed houses and healed.

1579 CE · 38.12, 13.36 · status: official

The sceptical view

Inquisitors treated the visions as diabolic; historians (Gustav Henningsen) see a living fairy cult.

The researched reading

Trial records of a real folk cult in which people travelled with fairies in dreams and trances. Culture and visionary experience explain it.

ExplanationWeightWhy
A cultural story40%Gustav Henningsen’s study of the Palermo trials shows a living Sicilian fairy cult: women claimed to join night companies who blessed houses and healed, and inquisitors recast this as diabolism.
Perception, memory or mind33%The night journeys were experienced in dreams, trance or sleep states; people sincerely described visionary experiences shaped by local belief, much like the Friulian benandanti.
Undetermined16%The share the reading had given to fabrication on doubt rather than evidence: the record does not settle it either way.
A hoax or fabrication5%Some healers made a living from their fairy contacts and may have embellished them for clients.
A known natural phenomenon3%No physical phenomenon is needed to explain the accounts.
Genuinely anomalous3%There is no evidence that the fairy companies existed outside the visions.

Official position: The Sicilian Inquisition judged the accounts diabolic illusion and punished the accused, usually mildly.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Donas de fuera
  2. Benandanti (Wikipedia)
Open it in the living atlas