Case file · Official inquiry

Alitalia near-miss over Lydd

On 21 April 1991 the captain of an Alitalia MD-80 bound for Heathrow saw a three-metre, khaki-coloured object pass about 300 metres away over Lydd, Kent, at 22,000 feet.

1991 CE · 50.95, 0.91 · status: unexplained

The account

Radar picked up a contact. The UK Civil Aviation Authority investigated it as an Airprox (near-miss) and could not identify the object; a missile was ruled out.

The sceptical view

Balloons or a toy rocket are possible; the CAA report left it unidentified.

The researched reading

A close daylight encounter with a small object near Heathrow’s approaches that was never identified. A balloon or unreported military object is likelier than anything stranger, but the case remains open.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Something known, misidentified40%A small khaki or brown, missile-shaped object with no exhaust seen briefly at 22,000 feet fits a balloon or other drifting object; the radar echo was faint and some 10 nautical miles behind the airliner, not clearly the same object.
Secret human technology20%The pilot thought it was a missile; the inquiry ruled out the Lydd army ranges and space activity, but an unreported military target drone or test cannot be wholly excluded.
Genuinely anomalous18%A pilot and co-pilot report, a radar echo of uncertain relevance and an official failure to identify it leave real room.
Perception, memory or mind10%Size and distance of a fleeting object are very hard to judge at closing speed.
Undetermined6%The share a generic explanation had beyond what has been shown for this case: it fits many cases like this one, but has not been demonstrated for this one.
A known natural phenomenon3%A daylight object at close range is unlikely to be an optical effect.
A poorly understood natural phenomenon2%Nothing suggests a natural luminous phenomenon.
A hoax or fabrication1%Reported by the captain through official channels.

Official position: The CAA and Ministry of Defence inquiry could not identify the object; missiles and space activity were ruled out.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: UFO sightings in the United Kingdom
  2. Alitalia near-miss (Hansard, 14 May 1991)
  3. UK air-miss cases (Patrick Gross)
Open it in the living atlas