Case file · Cryptid

The Beast of Exmoor

In 1983 a South Molton farmer, Eric Ley, said he had lost more than 100 sheep in three months to throat wounds; the Ministry of Agriculture sent Royal Marine marksmen onto Exmoor.

1983 CE · 51.02, -3.83 · status: disputed

The account

The marines saw a dark cat-like animal but never had a clear shot. The 'Beast of Exmoor' became the model for many British big-cat scares.

The sceptical view

Dogs, foxes and natural deaths explain most livestock losses; no big cat was ever shot or trapped on Exmoor.

The researched reading

A real run of sheep losses, a marksmen hunt and a legend. Dogs and foxes explain most of the killing, with a possible escaped cat as a lesser alternative.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Something known, misidentified50%Sheep losses with throat wounds fit dogs and foxes, and black dogs, large domestic cats and foxes seen at distance are often mistaken for big cats; the Royal Marines saw a dark animal but never got a clear shot or photograph.
An unknown or out-of-place animal15%Escaped or released exotic cats (pumas, leopards, lynx) did occur in Britain after the 1976 Dangerous Wild Animals Act, and a few were caught or killed elsewhere; a short-lived escaped cat on Exmoor is possible though no body was ever found.
A cultural story15%The "Beast" became a press brand and folklore figure, and Exmoor already had black dog legends.
Perception, memory or mind10%Once a beast is announced, every dark shape and dead sheep becomes evidence.
A hoax or fabrication8%Some later photographs and tracks were faked or misattributed.
Genuinely anomalous2%An escaped cat would not be anomalous; nothing beyond that is supported.

Official position: The Ministry of Agriculture sent Royal Marines; no animal was shot or caught.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: British big cats
  2. Beast of Exmoor (Wikipedia)
Open it in the living atlas