Case file · Fairy lore

Joan of Arc's 'Ladies' Tree'

At her trial in Rouen in 1431, judges questioned Joan of Arc about the 'Ladies' Tree' (Arbre des Dames) near Domrémy, where fairies were said to dance and children hung garlands.

1431 CE · 48.44, 5.68 · status: official

The account

Joan answered that she had heard of fairies there but never seen one. The judges used the tree to suggest she consorted with spirits; the record is one of the best medieval sources on village fairy belief.

The researched reading

One of the best medieval records of village fairy custom, preserved because judges tried to use it against Joan. It is folklore, honestly recorded.

ExplanationWeightWhy
Undetermined42%The share a generic explanation had beyond what has been shown for this case: it fits many cases like this one, but has not been demonstrated for this one.
A cultural story40%The trial record shows ordinary village custom: children hung garlands at a beech known as the Ladies’ Tree and older people spoke of fairies there; Joan said she had never seen one, and the judges used the tradition to insinuate witchcraft.
Perception, memory or mind9%Village fairy belief rested on stories and occasional experiences rather than any sighting recorded here.
A known natural phenomenon3%A spring and an old tree at the edge of a wood are natural gathering places; nothing physical needs explaining.
A hoax or fabrication3%The prosecution exaggerated the tree’s meaning, but the custom itself was real.
Genuinely anomalous3%No witness at the trial claimed to have seen fairies.

Official position: The 1431 court used the tree as part of its case; the 1456 nullification trial rejected the charges.

Connections in the atlas

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Trial of Joan of Arc
Open it in the living atlas