The CIA's 1952 flying-saucer study (Chadwell memos)
In August-October 1952 the CIA's Office of Scientific Intelligence reviewed the Air Force's UFO work. It warned the Director that saucers carried national-security risks of panic and air-defence confusion.
1952 CE · 38.90, -77.05 · status: official
The account
After the July 1952 Washington sightings, OSI briefed the Agency on 14 August. It reviewed reports back to the Swedish 'ghost rockets' of 1946 and weighed four theories, finding 'no shred of evidence' for interplanetary craft. H. Marshall Chadwell's memos of 24 September and 2 October 1952 counted about 1,500 official reports since 1947, with 20% unexplained (28% for January-July 1952). He judged ATIC's case-by-case method valid but unable to identify the phenomena. His consultants thought answers might lie 'on the margins or just beyond the frontiers' of atmospheric, ionospheric and extraterrestrial phenomena. He named two dangers: mass hysteria, and being unable to 'distinguish hardware from phantom' during an attack. He proposed going to the National Security Council and the Psychological Strategy Board, plus a public policy to 'minimize concern and possible panic'. A 13 October memo by James Q. Reber found no evidence that the saucers were Soviet. The study led directly to the Robertson Panel of January 1953.
The sceptical view
The files show worry about public reaction and radar confusion, not hidden knowledge. Draft briefings attribute most sightings to balloons, aircraft, astronomy and radar anomalies, while admitting a residue of 'incredible reports from credible observers'.
Connections in the atlas
- CIA history ties UFO reports to the U-2
- Air Defense Command on 'fast tracks' and radar phantoms
- CIA press digest: saucers over Spain and North Africa, 1952
- Gorman 'dogfight', Fargo
- The Robertson Panel report ('Durant report')
- The Robertson Panel
- Mantell incident
- Project Blue Book begins
- Washington D.C. flap
Sources
- OSI 'Flying Saucers' file: Chadwell memos and briefings, Aug-Oct 1952 (CIA, CIA-RDP81R00560R000100020012-7)
- Chadwell memo 'Flying Saucers' to the DCI, 2 Oct 1952, with Tab A of 24 Sep 1952 (CIA, DOC_0005515933)
- OSI briefing 'Flying Saucers', 14 Aug 1952 (CIA, CIA-RDP81R00560R000100020013-6)
- Reber memo 'Flying Saucers', 13 Oct 1952 (CIA, CIA-RDP81R00560R000100020011-8)
- Gerald K. Haines, 'CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, 1947-90', Studies in Intelligence 1997 (CIA, DOC_0005517742)